"Wagner’s voice is amazing in range, subtlety and versatility. Her acting reflects innate ability that cannot be learned, but apparently can be trained to attain heights reserved for a very few... Worth the price of admission to observe Jessica Wagner weave her spell over an audience.​" - The River Reporter

“Jessica Wagner caresses every lyric and melody, this marvelous performer grabs hold of her audience right from the start." - Digital First Media

"Jessica Wagner sings like a dream." - BackStage

"What else can be said about the amazing Jessica Wagner? She has consistently demonstrated that she can handle any role at all. When she smiles, the whole house smiles with her and when she sings, we hold our breath, not wanting to miss a single note."​ - The Sullivan County Democrat